Franchise opportunities compared

    CARSTAR vs Maaco

    Reviewed figures from each brand's Franchise Disclosure Document (FDD), side by side. Each figure carries its FDD year and page. This is not a ranking or recommendation, and the two FDDs may cover different years and location groups.

    Initial investment · Item 7

    CARSTAR

    $23,500 – $804,300

    2025 FDD · Item 7

    Maaco

    $196,000 – $728,500

    2025 FDD · Item 7

    Initial franchise fee · Item 5

    CARSTAR

    $10,000

    2025 FDD · Item 5 · PDF p. 29

    Maaco

    $45,000

    2025 FDD · Item 5 · PDF p. 30

    Royalty · Item 6

    CARSTAR

    1.5% or $1,000/mo min

    2025 FDD · Item 6 · PDF p. 36

    Maaco

    8% royalty

    2025 FDD · Item 6 · PDF p. 33

    Before you compare

    • Both sets of figures come from 2025 FDDs.
    • CARSTAR and Maaco disclose more than one business format, so the investment range spans formats; the full report breaks them out.
    • Item 19 figures cover the location groups each FDD names (CARSTAR: 19, Maaco: 15). Different groups are not directly comparable.

    Financial commitment

    Estimated initial investment (Item 7)

    CARSTAR

    $23,500 – $804,300
    2025 FDD · Item 7

    Maaco

    $196,000 – $728,500
    2025 FDD · Item 7
    Standard initial franchise fee (Item 5)

    CARSTAR

    $10,000
    2025 FDD · Item 5 · PDF p. 29

    Maaco

    $45,000
    Item 5 also lists discounted fees for additional centers and states that 2024 initial fees ranged from $5,000 to $45,000.
    2025 FDD · Item 5 · PDF p. 30
    Royalty (Item 6)

    CARSTAR

    1.5% or $1,000/mo min
    Monthly Base Franchise Fee
    2025 FDD · Item 6 · PDF p. 36

    Maaco

    8% royalty
    Standard royalty fee
    2025 FDD · Item 6 · PDF p. 33
    Brand / advertising fund (Item 6)

    CARSTAR

    $500
    Insurance and Marketing Fund Fee minimum
    2025 FDD · Item 6 · PDF p. 31

    Maaco

    $15,000
    Initial advertising contribution
    2025 FDD · Item 6 · PDF p. 32

    System scale & health

    Total outlets (Item 20)

    CARSTAR

    471
    Outlets at end of 2024
    2025 FDD · Item 20 · PDF p. 82

    Maaco

    726
    Outlets at end of 2024
    2025 FDD · Item 20 · PDF p. 79
    Net outlet change (Item 20)

    CARSTAR

    +25
    Calculated: 446 at end of 2022 → 471 at end of 2024

    Maaco

    −70
    Calculated: 796 at end of 2022 → 726 at end of 2024
    Outlet exits (Item 20)

    CARSTAR

    32
    Closures, terminations & non-renewals in 2024 · Calculated turnover 7.0% of outlets at start of year
    2025 FDD · Item 20 · PDF p. 82

    Maaco

    19
    Closures, terminations & non-renewals in 2024 · Calculated turnover 2.5% of outlets at start of year
    2025 FDD · Item 20 · PDF p. 79
    Franchising since (Item 1)

    CARSTAR

    Not available
    Not in reviewed records

    Maaco

    Not available
    Not in reviewed records
    Franchisor founded (Item 1)

    CARSTAR

    Not available
    Not in reviewed records

    Maaco

    Not available
    Not in reviewed records

    Financial performance (Item 19), by location group

    CARSTAR
    Locations counted not stated in the reviewed record — CARSTAR franchised facilities, Bottom 50% by 2024 average Gross Sales
    198 units
    other Part A
    2025 FDD · Item 19 · PDF p. 78
    Locations counted not stated in the reviewed record — CARSTAR franchised facilities, Top 50% by 2024 average Gross Sales
    199 units
    other Part A
    2025 FDD · Item 19 · PDF p. 78
    Locations counted not stated in the reviewed record — Part B franchisee-operated facilities converting existing repair businesses; FY…
    $1,340,572
    other Part B
    2025 FDD · Item 19 · PDF p. 80
    +16 more groups in the full report
    Maaco
    Locations counted not stated in the reviewed record — Bottom 50% of franchised Maaco Centers meeting Part A criteria for the 2024 Fis…
    $445,821
    other Lowest gross receipts
    2025 FDD · Item 19 · PDF p. 76
    Locations counted not stated in the reviewed record — FY 2023 Openings, Year 1
    $786,313
    other Part B
    2025 FDD · Item 19 · PDF p. 78
    Locations counted not stated in the reviewed record — Franchised Maaco Centers meeting Part A operating and reporting criteria for th…
    317 centers
    other Item 19 Part A
    2025 FDD · Item 19 · PDF p. 75
    +12 more groups in the full report

    Item 19 groups are shown separately and never combined. Revenue or sales figures are not profit. Net outlet change and turnover are Franopolis calculations from the disclosed counts; turnover is a count-based rate, not a measure of owner earnings.

    CARSTAR vs Maaco: common questions

    Which costs less to open, CARSTAR or Maaco?
    CARSTAR: $23,500 – $804,300 (2025 FDD · Item 7); Maaco: $196,000 – $728,500 (2025 FDD · Item 7). These are each franchisor's Item 7 estimated initial investment. The low end of the disclosed estimate is lower for CARSTAR. At least one range spans several business formats. Estimates are not quotes, and the FDD years may differ.
    How do CARSTAR and Maaco royalties compare?
    CARSTAR: 1.5% or $1,000/mo min (2025 FDD · Item 6 · PDF p. 36); Maaco: 8% royalty (2025 FDD · Item 6 · PDF p. 33). Royalties as disclosed in Item 6; other recurring fees are listed separately.
    Which has more locations, CARSTAR or Maaco?
    CARSTAR: 471 (2025 FDD · Item 20 · PDF p. 82); Maaco: 726 (2025 FDD · Item 20 · PDF p. 79). Total outlets from Item 20. Outlet counts do not indicate territory availability or franchisee results.
    Do CARSTAR and Maaco disclose financial performance (Item 19)?
    CARSTAR has reviewed Item 19 figures for 19 location groups; Maaco has reviewed Item 19 figures for 15 location groups. Different location groups are not directly comparable, and revenue is not profit.

    Answers restate the reviewed figures above. Not a ranking or recommendation.

    How Franopolis reviews FDD figures

    Keep researching